Cold vs Hot Process Soap: What’s the Difference Between Hot and Cold Process Soap?
When it comes to soap-making, there's an age-old debate brewing: is cold or hot process soap better? It’s a bit like arguing whether tea or coffee is the right answer - both have their place, but they cater to different tastes.
You might be thinking, "Soap is soap, right?" Oh, how delightfully mistaken you are! Making soap is a delicate art, and choosing between cold vs hot process soap is one of the first decisions you’ll have to make.
So, let’s dive into one of the ultimate soap-nerd topics. We’ll explain the difference between hot and cold process soap, make the arguments for both, and help you decide which method is right for you. No pressure!
Making your own soap is a fun (but intense) activity, but what if you want premium, small-batch, artisan soap without spending weeks reading up on how to make it and small a fortune on ingredients? That’s where we come in. Hi!
Oshun has the best goat milk soap, made lovingly from the world’s most hydrating, nourishing, exfoliating ingredients. It’s gentle, versatile, luxurious, creamy, and it gives you a healthy glow that big-brand, chemical-filled soaps can’t even imagine. Get yours today and see for yourself!
What’s the Difference Between Hot and Cold Process Soap?
Is cold or hot process soap better? Wait, hold on. First things first, what’s the difference between hot and cold process soap? Excellent question - here’s what you need to know.
Overview of Cold Process Soap
Cold process soap-making is the purist’s approach, especially in terms of how to make goat milk soap. It’s a slower, more methodical method that involves mixing oils (like olive or coconut) with lye at room or slightly elevated temperatures.
The mixture then goes through saponification (the chemical reaction that turns fats into soap) over time, without the need for heat. Once the mixture is poured into molds, it takes about 4 to 6 weeks to fully cure. Yes, you’re playing the long game here.
Overview of Hot Process Soap
Hot process soap, on the other hand, speeds things up by using heat to accelerate the saponification process. After mixing the oils and lye, the mixture is heated, often in a slow cooker or double boiler, until it reaches a thick, mashed-potato-like consistency.
The soap is then ready to pour into molds and cool, and because the saponification is already complete, it’s ready to use in just a few days after cooling. If you’re in a hurry to get your soap into the world (or your shower), hot process is for you.
Cold vs Hot Process Soap: Which Method is Better?
We’ve talked about the difference between hot and cold process soap, but which is actually better? That, my friend, is for you to decide, but we’ll give you the info you need to choose between cold vs hot process soap.
Which Process Retains Nutrients Better?
Cold process soap has the upper hand when it comes to preserving the natural nutrients in oils, butters, and other additives. Since this method doesn't involve high heat, ingredients like essential oils, vitamins, and other skin-loving goodies retain more of their beneficial properties.
If you’re making soap with a lot of nutrients, like goat milk soap, and that nutrient value is important to you, cold process soap might be the best option. Curious to see how the nutrient profile of goat milk soap compares to other options? You can find that info here:
- Goat milk soap vs coconut milk soap
- Donkey milk soap vs goat milk soap
- Sheep vs goat milk soap
- Goat milk soap vs regular soap
- Cow milk soap vs goat milk soap
- Tallow vs goat milk soap
- Shea butter vs goat milk soap
In contrast, the hot process method uses heat to accelerate saponification, which can cause some sensitive nutrients to break down. However, since the soap cooks before you add any extra ingredients, you can still mix in delicate additives like essential oils after the soap has cooled.
Which Process is More Suitable for Sensitive Skin?
For sensitive skin, cold process soap generally takes the lead. The extended curing period allows the lye to fully neutralize, resulting in a milder, gentler soap and a smooth texture. If you’re making goat milk soap for sensitive skin, you can avoid adding common irritants, like artificial fragrances or dyes.
Hot process soap can also be suitable for sensitive skin, but it’s usually not as smooth and may feel a bit rougher or less refined on the skin at first. That said, you can still control the ingredients in hot process soap and use gentle, skin-friendly oils and butters.
Comparing Curing Times and When the Soap is Ready to Use
Probably the biggest difference between hot and cold process soap is the curing times. Cold process soap requires patience - about 4 to 6 weeks of curing time. During this period, the soap hardens, becomes milder, and develops a longer-lasting bar.
Hot process soap, on the other hand, only needs a few days to cool and harden before it’s ready to use. If you’re someone who wants instant gratification (or soap), hot process soap might be the better choice.
Which Method is More Beginner-Friendly?
Is cold vs hot process soap better for soap noobs? Generally, hot process. Because saponification happens during the cooking stage, there’s less risk of lye being left in the soap, reducing the chances of a batch going wrong.
The thick consistency also means there's less fuss with pouring, though it’s harder to create intricate designs. The cost to make goat milk soap can be high, so you don’t want to waste ingredients. If you’re new, you might want to start with hot process soap.
Cold process soap, while a bit more challenging, comes with more creative freedom and smoother, prettier bars. However, it requires more precision in the measurements and a bit of chemistry knowledge to get the lye ratios just right.
If you’re looking for a speedy, rustic soap that’s a bit rough around the edges, hot press soap is for you. If you’re up for a challenge and willing to wait for that perfect, silky bar, cold process is a rewarding journey.
More Considerations in Choosing a Quality Soap
If you’re making soap, it’s essential to understand the difference between cold vs hot process soap. If you’re buying soap, it’s still important, but there are lots of other factors that go into making a quality bar of soap.
We should know - Oshun has the best goat milk soap, made with skin-loving ingredients. If you’re wondering where to buy goat milk soap that’s hydrating, nourishing, and exfoliating all in one, you’ve come to the right place!
Plus, there are so many different Oshun goat milk soap uses. You can use goat milk soap for eczema, goat milk soap for acne, and goats milk soap for psoriasis - it’s gentle enough for even the most sensitive skin. Can you use goat milk soap on your hair? You bet, it’s better than most shampoo!
Whether you’re looking for the best soap for aging skin (it really does wind back the years) or a goat milk soap for laundry detergent (less glamorous but still effective), discover the incredible benefits of goat milk soap with the best in the business, Oshun.
Ingredient Quality and Sourcing
The ingredients in goat milk soap matter, they really do. High-quality soaps typically use plant-based oils and butters (think olive oil, shea butter, or coconut oil) that are rich in nutrients and gentle on the skin.
When choosing soap, look for products that use sustainably sourced, organic ingredients. Not only do these soaps bring more benefits, but they also ensure fewer chemicals, pesticides, or artificial preservatives touch your skin, thank you very much.
Sourcing matters, too. A soap made with fair trade or ethically harvested ingredients can give you peace of mind that workers and the environment weren't exploited in the process. Always check labels or ask makers about the origin of their materials. What's good for the planet is usually good for your skin, too.
Understanding Additives: Scents, Colors, and Exfoliants
Soap-making often involves additives to enhance the soap’s scent, color, or exfoliating properties. For scents, natural essential oils are much better than synthetic fragrances, which can sometimes cause irritation or allergic reactions.
When it comes to color, natural pigments like clays or botanical extracts are the way to go. Avoid soaps with artificial dyes, which don’t offer any skin benefits and can sometimes be harsh, especially for sensitive skin.
Exfoliants like oatmeal, coffee grounds, or poppy seeds can give your soap that little extra oomph for sloughing away dead skin. However, if you have sensitive skin, you might want to opt for gentler exfoliants or none at all.
Soap Longevity and Storage Needs
A quality soap isn’t just about how it feels on your skin—it’s also about how long it lasts. To make your soap last longer, think about how you’re storing it. Keep it in a well-draining soap dish to prevent it from sitting in water, which can turn even the best quality soap into a soggy mess.
Some cold process soaps, due to their longer curing time, are naturally harder and more durable, which extends their lifespan. Hot process soaps, while ready sooner, can have a more rustic texture that might break down faster if not stored properly.
How long does goat milk soap last? It actually gets better with age - don’t throw away an old bar because there’s almost a 100% chance that it’s perfectly fine. As long as it’s not sitting is a pool of water, your goat milk soap should pretty much last you forever!
Environmental and Ethical Considerations
In today’s world, what you wash with has as much impact on the environment as it does on your skin. Many mass-produced soaps are full of harmful chemicals and come wrapped in layers of unnecessary plastic packaging. Sigh.
Opting for handcrafted, small-batch soaps made with biodegradable ingredients helps reduce your ecological hoofprint. Look for soap brands that use minimal or eco-friendly packaging, such as recyclable paper or reusable containers.
Brands that prioritize fair trade, cruelty-free, kosher, or vegan certifications show that they care about both people and animals. Choosing soap from companies that are transparent about their production processes helps you make informed, ethical decisions while still pampering your skin. Win-win!
Bringing our Comparison of Cold Process vs Hot Process Soap to a Close
That wraps up our guide to cold vs hot process soap. In terms of soap making, the biggest difference between hot and cold process soap is the amount of time your soap cures for, with cold process soap taking 6-8 weeks and hot process soap being ready to use within a couple of days.
In terms of actually using cold process vs hot process soap, cold process soap tends to be smoother, softer, and more luxurious. Is it worth the wait? Almost always. Hot process soap is a little more rustic and rough around the edges, but it still gets the job done.
So, is cold or hot process soap better? That’s really up to you, but it’s safe to say that just about any small-batch soap that’s made with love and premium ingredients is better than most of the mass-produced options on your store’s shelves.
If you can’t choose between making cold process vs hot process soap, choose Oshun! That way, you won’t have to make any soap at all, and you can still treat your skin to the absolute pinnacle of luxury. Get yours today and make every day a spa day!
