Sheep Milk Soap vs Goat Milk Soap: Which is Better for You?

When it comes to natural skincare, milk-based soaps have gained a devoted following for their gentle, nourishing properties. If you want soft, vibrant, youthful skin, these are a far better option than the traditional soaps and bodywashes you see lining the shelves!

Among the most popular options are sheep milk soap and goat milk soap, both celebrated for their rich, creamy lather and skin-loving benefits. But when it comes to sheep milk soap vs goat milk soap, which is actually better for your skin? 

You can scroll down to read all about it, but we’ll tell you right now that our Oshun goat milk soap blows sheep milk out of the water. It’s so much more nourishing, better for sensitive skin, has incredible moisturizing powers, and couldn’t be gentler. Honestly, what more could you want?!

Why Natural Soaps are the Way to Go

Sadly, synthetic ingredients dominate the skincare industry. We’ve been putting harsh chemicals on our skin for far too long, and many of us are starting to feel the effects. That’s why natural soaps have become such a refreshing alternative for happier, healthier skin. 

Unlike commercial soaps, which come with their chemicals, artificial fragrances, and preservatives, natural soaps are crafted from pure, simple ingredients that are gentle on your skin and kinder to the environment.

Most natural soaps only contain a few ingredients, and they’re easy to pronounce! Made from natural oils, fats, and butters, these soaps provide essential moisture without stripping your skin of its natural oils. Some also have herbal extracts, essential oils, and milks, which soothe, nourish, and protect your skin.

Natural soaps are also often free from synthetic fragrances and dyes, making them ideal for sensitive skin or anyone prone to allergies. The mild, natural scents derived from essential oils not only offer a pleasing aroma but also provide aromatherapeutic benefits.

Overview of Sheep Milk Soap

Sheep milk soap is a luxurious, nutrient-rich option that has been prized for its skin-loving properties for centuries. Made from the milk of sheep, this soap is known for its high-fat content, which contributes to its creamy texture and moisturizing abilities. 

Sheep milk contains a rich blend of vitamins and minerals, including vitamins A, B, and E, as well as zinc, which are all beneficial for maintaining healthy skin. Sheep milk is also rich in lactic acid, a natural alpha-hydroxy acid (AHA) that gently exfoliates the skin. 

This mild exfoliation helps to remove dead skin cells, revealing a smoother, more radiant complexion. The natural exfoliating properties of sheep milk soap make it particularly beneficial for individuals with rough or uneven skin texture.

The high fat and protein content in sheep milk helps to create a thick, velvety lather that not only cleanses but also leaves the skin feeling soft and supple. This makes sheep milk soap a good choice for those with dry or sensitive skin, as it helps to lock in moisture and prevent irritation.

Overview of Goat Milk Soap

What about goat milk, is goat milk soap good for your skin? Absolutely! It’s a beloved choice in the world of natural skincare, known for its gentle, soothing properties and ability to nourish even the most sensitive skin. 

This soap is packed with vitamins, minerals, and beneficial fats that contribute to its creamy texture and moisturizing qualities. This moisturizing power is where many of the benefits of goat milk soap come from - it can work miracles for dry skin!

Goat milk also contains high levels of fatty acids and triglycerides (learn about TFM in soap here), which help to replenish the skin’s natural moisture barrier, keeping it soft and hydrated without the need for added synthetic moisturizers. 

Goat milk is also rich in vitamins A, D, and B6, as well as selenium, all of which are essential for maintaining healthy skin. Vitamin A, in particular, is known for its ability to promote skin cell turnover, helping to repair damaged skin and reduce the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. 

These nutrients make goat milk soap a nourishing choice that can help improve skin texture and tone, and the goat milk soap before and after results show you just how effective it can really be. 

Goat milk soap has a naturally low pH level, which closely matches the pH of human skin. This helps to maintain the skin’s natural balance, preventing dryness and irritation. It’s why many people use goat milk soap for eczema, goat milk soap for acne, and goats milk soap for psoriasis.

It’s not just your skin that benefits from goat milk soap! There are also goat milk soap benefits for hair, as well as many other goat milk soap uses like goat milk soap for dogs and goat milk soap for laundry detergent. But in terms of sheep milk soap vs goat milk soap, which is better?

Sheep Milk Soap vs Goat Milk Soap: Which is Better for You?

Choosing between sheep milk soap vs goat milk soap can be a tough decision, especially when both offer great benefits for your skin. Let’s take a look at the differences between these two natural soaps, helping you make the best choice for healthy, happy, glowing skin.

Comparison of Nutrient Profiles

Both sheep and goat milk soaps are rich in nutrients that benefit the skin, but there are some differences. Sheep milk is particularly high in fat content, which contributes to its moisturizing properties. It’s also rich in vitamins A, B, and E, along with essential minerals like zinc.

Goat milk is packed full of nutrients, boasting high levels of vitamin A, D, and B6, as well as selenium. These nutrients are essential for skin repair and maintenance. Goat milk also contains more lactic acid, a natural exfoliant that can help brighten and smooth the skin over time.

Effectiveness for Different Skin Types

Sheep milk soap, with its higher fat content, is excellent for dry or sensitive skin, providing deep hydration and a protective barrier that locks in moisture. Its gentle nature also makes it a suitable choice if you have eczema or psoriasis.

What does goat milk soap do for your skin? Goat milk soap has equally good moisturizing properties for dry skin, and it’s even better for sensitive skin due to its low pH level. It matches the skin's natural balance, making it a great choice for those with acne-prone or irritated skin. 

Is goat milk soap good for your face? Yes - goat milk soap has the ability to gently exfoliate and promote cell turnover without stripping the skin, making it ideal for sensitive skin types. It can also be beneficial for those dealing with conditions like rosacea or dermatitis.

Lather and Texture Comparison

The lather and texture of these soaps can influence your experience as well. Sheep milk soap tends to produce a rich, creamy lather due to its high fat content, offering a luxurious feel that leaves your skin feeling soft and pampered. 

Goat milk soap lathers just as well, making goat milk shaving soap a popular choice. It creates a gentle, smooth lather that cleanses effectively while still being easy to rinse off. If you prefer a lighter, quicker-lathering soap, goat milk soap might be the better option for you.

Scent Profiles

Sheep milk soap often has a mild, creamy scent that is subtly earthy. This natural aroma can be enhanced with essential oils, but it typically remains gentle and unobtrusive - it’s not overly strong unless from added fragrances. 

What does goat milk soap smell like? Like sheep milk soap, it depends on the specific ingredients in goat milk soap, and whether there are any added essential oils or fragrances. On its own, goat milk soap has a mild scent, often described as fresh and clean with a hint of sweetness. 

Price and Availability

Sheep milk soap is often considered more of a niche product and may be slightly more expensive due to the higher fat content and smaller production scale. It may also be hard to find, depending on where you live.

The cost to make goat milk soap is generally lower, making it a more affordable option. Because it’s so popular, goat milk soap is commonly found in stores and online, and there are often more varieties and formulations to choose from, making it easier to find the perfect goat milk soap for your skin.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

Sheep farming can have a larger environmental footprint due to the resources required to farm sheep, but when sourced from ethical, small-scale farms, sheep milk soap can be a sustainable choice. But, if environmental impact and animal welfare are your top priorities, goat milk soap has the edge.

Goat farming is generally considered more sustainable, as goats require less land and resources than sheep. Many goat milk soap producers also emphasize ethical farming practices, including humane treatment of animals and sustainable land use. 

So, Which is Right For You?

Ultimately, the choice between sheep milk soap vs goat milk soap comes down to your individual skincare needs and personal values, but it’s clear to see that goat milk soap has the edge over sheep milk soap in some categories. 

Both lather well and are deeply hydrating and nourishing, but goat milk soap’s lower pH makes it a better option for those with sensitive skin or certain skin conditions. Plus, goat milk soap offers better exfoliation, is more widely available at a lower cost, and is better for the planet. There’s a clear winner!

If you’re interested in learning how goat milk soap compares to other types of soaps out there, check out our guides on: 

• Donkey milk soap vs goat milk soap
• Goat milk soap vs regular soap
• Cow milk soap vs goat milk soap
• Goat milk soap vs coconut milk soap
• Goat milk soap vs regular soap

See For Yourself Why Goat Milk Soap is the Superior Choice at Oshun!

Don’t just take our word for it, though - try the best goat milk soap and feel the difference for yourself! If you’re not sure where to buy goat milk soap, you’re already in the right place. Here at Oshun, we have the best, most nourishing goat milk soap for your skin.  

We know how to make goat milk soap. We’ve spent years searching the planet for the finest ingredients, all responsibly sourced, to bring you the best, most natural soap your skin has ever felt. The best part? We said no to chemicals, microplastics, and shady practices. 

Instead, we embraced small-batch production, the world’s most incredible ingredients, and transparency every step of the way. We know your skin will feel the difference, because it’s infused into every bar of our premium, 8-ingredient goat milk soap. 

Bringing Our Sheep Milk Soap vs Goat Milk Soap Comparison to a Close

When it comes to sheep milk soap vs goat milk soap, they’re both good options. But, goat milk soap clearly has the upper hand, especially if you have sensitive skin. With a low pH and insane moisturizing power, it’s the best choice for dry, sensitive skin, and everyone else as well! 

Here at Oshun, we’ve spent years perfecting our minimalist formula and sourcing renewable, handpicked ingredients that are worthy of your skin. Our small-batch goat milk soap feels better for your skin, because it is better! 

Ready to love the skin you’re in? Try Oshun today - you’ll never look back!