Tallow vs Goat Milk Soap

Have you noticed just how many soaps there are out there? It honestly feels like there’s a soap designed for everyone, whether you have dry skin that needs extra moisture, sensitive skin that can’t handle additives, or just need to get clean and smell good. 

Finding the right soap can sometimes feel like speed dating, but we’re here to help (not with the dating part). Today, we’ll help you understand two important ingredients to narrow down your soap choices: tallow vs goat milk soap. 

Tallow has rich, moisturizing properties but, let’s be honest, comes from animal fat. Then there’s goat milk - luxuriously creamy, nutrient-packed, and, dare we say, a bit more refined? The choice is yours, but we’ll explain why goat milk soap has that je ne sais quoi that can be the difference between good and great skin. 

Overview of Goat Milk and Tallow Soap

What is goat milk soap, and what is tallow? Before we compare tallow vs goat milk soap, let’s take a look at each of these ingredients separately, and how they’re similar. 

What is Goat Milk Soap?

Goat milk soap is a creamy, indulgent bar crafted from (you guessed it) fresh goat milk. There are so many skin benefits of goat milk soap - it’s packed with vitamins like A and E, as well as fatty acids, and is a favorite among those with sensitive or dry skin. 

Its lactic acid content gently exfoliates while the milk’s natural fats deeply moisturize, making it a luxurious choice for a soft, hydrated complexion. Plus, the proteins found in goat milk help maintain your skin’s natural pH, giving you that oh-so-balanced glow.

What is Beef Tallow Soap?

Beef tallow soap is made from rendered fat, traditionally from cows. While it might not sound glamorous, tallow has been used for centuries in soapmaking due to its high-fat content, which results in a hard, long-lasting bar. 

It’s rich in triglycerides that closely mimic our skin’s natural oils, making it effective at sealing in moisture. Tallow soap provides a creamy lather and a smooth after-feel, but its animal origins don’t sit well with everyone.

How Are They Similar?

We’ll talk about the differences between tallow vs goat milk soap next, but there are actually some similarities between the two as well. Both goat milk and tallow soaps are celebrated for their moisturizing properties and rich, creamy lathers. 

They’re also both available in all-natural varieties, making them a great alternative to commercial soaps packed with synthetic additives. In terms of texture, both produce a luxurious, velvety lather that leaves your skin feeling soft and nourished. 

Interested in how goat milk soap compares to some of the other options out there? These guides have the answers to all your burning questions: 

• Goat milk soap vs coconut milk soap
• Donkey milk soap vs goat milk soap
• Sheep vs goat milk soap
• Goat milk soap vs regular soap
• Cow milk soap vs goat milk soap

Tallow vs Goat Milk Soap: Key Differences to Consider

So, let’s dive in, shall we? What are the main differences between tallow vs goat milk soap, and why has goat milk soap stolen our hearts? 

Source of Fats: Animal Fat vs Dairy Milk

Tallow soap is primarily made from beef fat, a byproduct of the meat industry. This fat is rendered into a substance that’s highly moisturizing but undeniably animal-based. 

Goat milk soap sources its fats from the cream of goat milk, offering a more sophisticated blend of dairy goodness. While both are animal-derived, goat milk feels more indulgent, with its fats contributing to a creamier, more luxe experience - and isn’t that what your skin deserves?!

Nutritional Profile and Skin Benefits

The ingredients in goat milk soap are next-level. Goat milk is a powerhouse of nutrients, packed with vitamins like A, B6, B12, and E, along with beneficial fatty acids. These nourish the skin while promoting gentle exfoliation through its natural lactic acid. 

Tallow is also rich in vitamins, particularly A and D, but lacks the exfoliating acids found in goat milk. While both offer deep moisturization, goat milk’s complex nutritional profile makes it more versatile for treating sensitive or aging skin - it’s the best soap for aging skin, hands down. 

Texture and Lather

Tallow soap is known for creating a dense, creamy lather that’s long-lasting, but goat milk soap takes things up a notch with its extra-velvety texture, thanks to the natural fats and proteins in the milk. 

Goat milk soap produces a rich, luxurious lather that feels almost whipped, making every wash feel like a treat. If you’re looking for a more indulgent texture, goat milk soap tends to deliver that spa-like experience, without the price tag of an actual spa visit. 

Impact on Skin Conditions

Both tallow and goat milk soaps are great for moisturizing and can bring big benefits for dry skin. That said, goat milk soap for sensitive skin is the best choice, due to the milk’s gentle exfoliating properties and natural pH balance. 

As well as being the best option for sensitive skin, many people use goat milk soap for eczema, goat milk soap for acne, and goats milk soap for psoriasis. Its ability to calm inflammation and prevent irritation gives it the edge over tallow soap when it comes to treating specific skin conditions.

Environmental and Ethical Considerations

Tallow is derived from beef fat, which makes it a byproduct of the meat industry. If you’re concerned about sustainability, this might make you think twice about using tallow soap. Some tallow is sourced ethically, but you have to trust the brands telling you that. 

Goat milk, while also animal-based, typically comes from small farms where the goats are raised for dairy, not slaughter. This gives goat milk soap a gentler environmental footprint. Or should that be hoofprint?

Accessibility and Pricing

How does the price compare between tallow soap vs goat milk soap? Tallow soap tends to be more widely available and affordable, as beef fat is a common and inexpensive byproduct. But just like any product, there are both cheap and expensive tallow soap options to choose from. 

The cost to make goat milk soap is usually higher, due to sourcing fresh milk and the labor-intensive production process. The good news is that the added benefits of goat milk soap usually justify the higher price tag, and can you even put a price on happy skin, really?

Scent Breakdown

Tallow soap can sometimes have a faint, animalistic scent, which is often masked by added fragrances. Goat milk soap usually has a milder, more neutral scent that’s sometimes enhanced with essential oils or other natural fragrances. 

Versatility in Use Cases

Honestly, both of these soaps are highly versatile. Goat milk soap, especially, has almost unlimited potential. Common goat milk soap uses include face and body wash, but you can also use goat milk soap for laundry detergent and find goat milk shaving soap recipes. 

Can you use goat milk soap on your hair? Please do! Goat milk soap nourishes your scalp, repairs hair breakage, minimizes hair loss, and helps tame unruly locks. Plus, it’s more natural and gentle than most commercial shampoos out there!

Should You Try a Tallow and Goat Milk Soap Recipe? 

We get it, decisions are hard. Rather than choosing between tallow vs goat milk soap, can’t you combine the two? Let’s take a look. 

Benefits of Combining Tallow and Goat Milk in Soap

Together, goat milk and tallow soap give you a bar that delivers on both hydration and nourishment. Tallow’s natural fats help create a hard, long-lasting bar with a rich lather, while goat milk’s lactic acid gently exfoliates, brightens, and balances your skin’s pH. 

This is a great combo if you have dry or sensitive skin, as the deep moisturization of tallow is complemented nicely by goat milk’s soothing and regenerative properties. You can use it for your hands, face, or entire body - it couldn’t be more versatile!

Tips for Making Your Own Tallow and Goat Milk Soap

If you want to learn how to make goat milk soap with tallow, be warned - it’s a long, time-consuming activity (trust us, we know soap). The key is to start with the absolute finest ingredients out there - it will make all the difference to your end product. Opt for grass-fed tallow and fresh goat milk from ethical sources.

Use a cold-press method, as it preserves the natural fats and nutrients from both the tallow and goat milk, giving you soap with maximum nourishing powers. Just be sure to mix the lye with care when adding goat milk to avoid any curdling.

Since both tallow and goat milk are fairly neutral in scent, you have free rein to customize your soap’s fragrance. Try lavender, eucalyptus, or even a subtle blend of citrus and herbs for a luxurious touch with serious spa vibes.

Better Yet, Spoil Your Skin at Oshun With the #1 Goat Milk Soap Online!

We get it, you don’t necessarily have a spare 100 hours to spend making artisanal soap. Luckily, we do! Rather than stress over whether or not your soap is setting in its molds properly, why not just treat yourself to the most luxurious soap out there?

Wondering where to buy goat milk soap that’s safe for sensitive skin, rich in hydration and nourishment, and made from the world’s finest ingredients, responsibly sourced from all over the planet? At OSHUN, we simply have the best goat milk soap, full of ingredients to pamper your skin.

We produce our goat milk soap in small batches, to make sure we’re giving you the quality you deserve. After just one wash, you’ll feel the difference. It’s amazing what a dose of deep hydration and nourishment can do for your skin!  

Wrapping Up Our Comparison of Tallow Soap vs Goat Milk Soap

When it comes to tallow soap vs goat milk soap, we only really have one piece of advice: go with your goat! Goat milk is packed full of vitamins and key fatty acids that work wonders on your skin, and OSHUN’s goat milk soap is the best there is. 

Give yourself the kind of skin that will have people begging for your routine. Discover a premium, luxurious lather from OSHUN!